Genuine OEM filters · Free US shipping on every order · Order by 3 pm MT, ships same day · 365-day returns

Refrigerator water filter vs Brita pitcher: which is better for your home?

Whirlpool everydrop EDR1RXD1 Genuine Refrigerator Water Filter (Filter 1)
Genuine Whirlpool everydrop EDR1RXD1 (Filter 1)

Two popular ways to get filtered water, but they’re not equal

Brita pitchers and refrigerator water filters are both effective at improving water quality, but they work differently, cost differently, and suit different households. Here’s an honest comparison to help you decide which is right for your home, or whether you need both.

Filtration performance

Both use activated carbon. But the size and type of carbon media differs significantly.

Refrigerator filters typically use carbon block, a dense, compressed form of activated carbon that removes a broader range of contaminants more effectively. Many refrigerator filters are certified to NSF/ANSI 42, and some also to NSF/ANSI 53 or 401; check the listing for your exact model.

Brita standard pitchers use granular activated carbon (GAC), which is less dense and generally less effective at lead removal. Brita’s Longlast filter does carry NSF 53 certification for lead, but the standard Brita filter does not.

Verdict: refrigerator filter wins on filtration for most models.

Convenience

Refrigerator filter: filtered water on demand from the dispenser. Cold, immediately available, no refilling. Ice is also filtered automatically.

Brita: must be refilled manually and stored in the fridge. Running out of filtered water when the pitcher is empty is a real inconvenience.

Verdict: refrigerator filter wins clearly.

Cost comparison

Refrigerator filterBrita standard
Filter costAbout $26 to $61 per filter at our prices$6–$10 per filter
Filter life6 months / 125 to 300 gal (varies by model)2 months / 40 gal
Annual costAbout $52 to $122/year with two filters a year$36–$60/year
Initial hardware costBuilt into the fridge$25–$50 for pitcher

Annual costs are in the same range. The refrigerator filter costs more per unit but lasts much longer, and filtered ice is included at no extra cost.

When a Brita makes sense

  • Your refrigerator doesn’t have a built-in water filter
  • You rent and can’t modify the fridge
  • You want a portable solution for a second location

When the refrigerator filter wins

  • Your fridge has a built-in filter, use it
  • You want filtered ice as well as water
  • You want lead reduction, and your fridge filter is certified to NSF/ANSI 53
  • Convenience is a priority

The bottom line

If your refrigerator has a built-in water filter, using and maintaining it is almost always the better choice over a separate pitcher. It’s more convenient, filters a larger volume per cartridge, and typically offers better contaminant reduction. The only reason to prefer a Brita is if your fridge doesn’t have a filter housing.

Find your refrigerator filter with free US shipping:

Find the right filter in seconds

Search by refrigerator model, filter part number or photo.

Find My Filter